Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Guardrails: Marshall Herskovitz on Capitalism, Culture Wars and the Majority Democrats Still Need

Marshall Herskovitz tells Dr. Rod Berger that capitalism needs guardrails, Democrats need more than 48 percent, and nobody in America ever feels they have enough. Help Me Understand.

“Capitalism needs guardrails in order to function.” A week after the midterms, Marshall Herskovitz explains what he means, and why he thinks the guardrails came off 45 years ago.

Help Me Understand with Dr. Rod Berger. Emmy-winning writer, director and producer Marshall Herskovitz says Democrats won this year on a populist economic message and a step back from the culture wars, the same split the New York Times editorial board praised days earlier. Now he wants a majority of 55 or 60 percent that outlasts one election. Rod brings a moment from his gym that morning, a man in a shirt he labeled before he read it, and asks whether Americans are built to give up anything so someone else can rise. They work through borders and assimilation, Bernie Sanders and upward mobility, Chuck Schumer and younger leadership, and what Marshall calls the dark side of the bright side.

In this episode

0:00 Welcome to Help Me Understand

1:04 Tennessee and a thin margin

2:47 “Democrats went off the rails in 2020”

4:32 The shirt at the gym

5:36 The industry of rage

6:03 Beyond the 48 percent

7:56 Borders, and limits on good things

10:28 Why immigrants become Americans

12:13 America marketed itself to the world

15:17 The New York Times editorial board

17:51 Forty-five years of neoliberalism

21:45 Capitalism needs guardrails

23:09 Where Marshall parts with Bernie

24:09 Upward mobility, the phrase we stopped using

25:04 California’s billionaire tax

27:40 Schumer, Slotkin and younger leadership

28:32 A generational moment

30:12 Studs or drywall?

30:43 Take their power, not their money

33:34 Would you give up your seat?

35:56 Who would actually lose?

38:09 Never enough

40:01 The dark side of the bright side

41:53 More questions than answers

Questions this episode answers

What does Marshall Herskovitz mean when he says capitalism needs guardrails? He compares the economy to a sport. Competition produces abuse, so every game has rules and referees. He argues that 45 years of what he calls neoliberalism removed the referees and turned health care and much else into commodities, and that regulating capitalism is how you keep it working, not how you end it.

Why does he say Democrats need more than 48 percent? He calls a narrow win a squeaker, not a mandate. He reads this year’s results as voters rejecting Donald Trump more than embracing Democrats, and he wants an enduring majority of 55 or 60 percent built with independents, on economic issues most Americans already support.

Where does he part with Bernie Sanders? He admires Sanders and agrees with most of what he says. He disagrees with a focus on free or cheaper services. Americans, he argues, want the prosperity and upward mobility to afford what they need themselves.

Where does Rod push back? On human nature. Rod wonders whether people who feel they never have enough will accept any limit, even a small one, so others can have a chance. Marshall answers that for most Americans the change would mean getting more, not less, and that the only people who lose are the ones with so much they would barely notice.

Who is Marshall Herskovitz? An Emmy-winning writer, director and producer. He co-created thirtysomething, My So-Called Life and Once and Again, produced films including Traffic and Blood Diamond, and is President Emeritus of the Producers Guild of America.

About the hosts

Dr. Rod Berger has conducted more than 4,000 interviews across five continents. He is Editor-at-Large at Fair Observer and the author of The Narrative Edge: Authentic Storytelling That Meets the Moment (Wiley). Marshall Herskovitz is his friend and, on some episodes, his co-host.

Visit drrodberger.com · Get The Narrative Edge in hardcover

Help Me Understand is part of The Dangerous Ones. Have something you’re trying to understand? Call The People’s Hotline and leave a message: 503-212-4600.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?